Speak To An Expert
Get clear, personalised advice for your situation.
Jot down a few questions to make the most of your conversation.
Understanding unfair redundancy selection
If you think you have been chosen for redundancy unfairly, you may have rights under UK employment law. A redundancy selection must be based on a genuine business need and a fair process. Employers should not pick people for reasons that are discriminatory or otherwise unfair.
Common warning signs include being selected without proper scoring, not being told why you were chosen, or being judged against vague criteria. If your employer has not followed a fair procedure, you may be able to challenge the decision. Keep notes of meetings, emails, and any documents relating to the process.
What makes selection unfair?
Selection may be unfair if it is based on protected characteristics such as age, sex, race, disability, pregnancy, religion, or sexual orientation. It may also be unfair if you are chosen because you are on maternity leave, have asked for flexible working, or have raised workplace concerns.
An employer should use objective selection criteria, such as skills, qualifications, attendance, and performance, and apply them consistently. If the criteria are subjective or used inconsistently, that can strengthen your case. Employers should also consider whether any scores or evidence can be explained and challenged.
What your employer should do
Your employer should consult with you before making a final decision. This means giving you a chance to understand the situation, ask questions, and suggest alternatives. In many cases, they should also consider suitable alternative roles if any are available.
If 20 or more redundancies are proposed at one workplace within 90 days, collective consultation rules may apply. Your employer must follow additional steps, including consulting employee representatives. Failing to do so can affect the fairness of the redundancy process.
What you can do next
If you believe the selection was unfair, raise the issue as soon as possible. You can ask for the scoring matrix, the selection criteria, and an explanation of how the decision was made. It is often best to do this in writing so you have a record.
You may also be able to use your employer’s grievance or appeal process. If the redundancy has already led to dismissal, you may have a claim for unfair dismissal if you have at least two years’ continuous service, although discrimination claims can be brought regardless of length of service. Deadlines for tribunal claims are usually very short, so do not delay.
Getting help and protecting your position
You can seek help from a trade union, Citizens Advice, ACAS, or an employment solicitor. ACAS early conciliation is usually required before making an employment tribunal claim. Getting advice early can help you understand whether the process was lawful and what remedies may be available.
Possible outcomes may include redeployment, a better redundancy package, or compensation if you have a valid claim. Keep copies of all paperwork and continue to act professionally throughout the process. That can help you protect your position if the matter escalates.
Frequently Asked Questions
Rights unfair redundancy selection refers to a situation where an employee believes they were chosen for redundancy using unfair, discriminatory, or improper selection criteria, or without a fair process that respects their employment rights.
Signs of rights unfair redundancy selection can include inconsistent scoring, changing selection criteria, targeting one person without objective reasons, ignoring performance records, or selecting someone because of a protected characteristic or employee right.
Any employee or worker who believes they were selected unfairly for redundancy may be able to challenge rights unfair redundancy selection, especially if the process was discriminatory, procedurally unfair, or based on invalid criteria.
Evidence for rights unfair redundancy selection may include redundancy scoring sheets, emails, meeting notes, job descriptions, performance reviews, witness statements, and records showing that the selection process was unfair or inconsistent.
To prove rights unfair redundancy selection, you usually need to show that the employer used unfair criteria, failed to follow a fair process, treated you differently from others without reason, or relied on discrimination or retaliation.
Yes, discrimination can be part of rights unfair redundancy selection if the redundancy decision was influenced by sex, race, age, disability, religion, pregnancy, maternity, union activity, or another protected characteristic.
Yes, rights unfair redundancy selection can happen during consultation if the employer already decided who would be dismissed, failed to genuinely consult, or used the consultation stage as a formality rather than a real process.
If you suspect rights unfair redundancy selection, you should ask for the selection criteria, request your scoring, gather documents, raise the issue internally, and consider taking advice from a union representative, HR adviser, or employment lawyer.
Yes, you may be able to appeal rights unfair redundancy selection through your employer's internal appeal process, grievance procedure, or other workplace dispute procedure if one is available.
Compensation for rights unfair redundancy selection may include a tribunal award, compensation for lost earnings, and in some cases additional damages if discrimination or other unlawful conduct is proven.
Deadlines for challenging rights unfair redundancy selection are usually strict, and employment claims often have short time limits, so you should act quickly and seek advice as soon as possible.
Yes, rights unfair redundancy selection can amount to unfair dismissal if the redundancy reason was not genuine, the process was unfair, or the employer failed to act reasonably in selecting and dismissing employees.
No, rights unfair redundancy selection does not require a scoring system, but if scoring is used it must be objective, consistent, and based on fair criteria that are applied properly to all affected employees.
Yes, rights unfair redundancy selection may be unlawful if an employee was disadvantaged because of maternity leave, paternity leave, adoption leave, parental leave, or pregnancy-related absence.
Yes, sickness absence can affect rights unfair redundancy selection if it is used unfairly or in a discriminatory way, especially where the absence is linked to disability or another protected reason.
Consultation in rights unfair redundancy selection should allow employees to understand the reasons for redundancy, ask questions, challenge scoring, and suggest alternatives before any final decision is made.
Yes, rights unfair redundancy selection may be unlawful if an employee is selected because of union membership, union activities, or trade union representation.
Yes, a poorly chosen redundancy pool can contribute to rights unfair redundancy selection if the employer excludes relevant employees, targets a narrow group unfairly, or creates the pool in a biased way.
Rights unfair redundancy selection is about the fairness of choosing a person for redundancy, while a genuine redundancy is when the role itself disappears or the need for work changes; an employer can have a genuine redundancy but still carry out selection unfairly.
Yes, it is usually a good idea to get legal advice about rights unfair redundancy selection because deadlines are short and the legal issues can be complex, especially if discrimination or unfair dismissal may apply.
Ergsy Search Results
This website offers general information and is not a substitute for professional advice.
Always seek guidance from qualified professionals.
If you have any medical concerns or need urgent help, contact a healthcare professional or emergency services immediately.
Some of this content was generated with AI assistance. We've done our best to keep it accurate, helpful, and human-friendly.
- Ergsy carefully checks the information in the videos we provide here.
- Videos shown by Youtube after a video has completed, have NOT been reviewed by ERGSY.
- To view, click the arrow in centre of video.
- Most of the videos you find here will have subtitles and/or closed captions available.
- You may need to turn these on, and choose your preferred language.
- Go to the video you'd like to watch.
- If closed captions (CC) are available, settings will be visible on the bottom right of the video player.
- To turn on Captions, click settings.
- To turn off Captions, click settings again.